Sunday, July 17, 2016

Field Position Part II


In a previous post I discussed how INTs and INT return yardage influenced starting field position (SFP). I will extend that discussion to include each of the other events that directly result in SFP: turnover-fumble returns, kick and punt returns, and missed field goals by opponents. As an aspiring defensive back, I of course took great care discussing interceptions. I will devote little discussion here to fumble recoveries and missed field goals. I will harp on kick-off returns but refrain from discussing punt returns at any depth.

Let me first state that my play-by-play (PBP) data differs slightly from the official record. I excluded yardage gained on returns for TDs in the analysis because a TD precludes SFP. Excluded also was return yardage gained prior to a turnover-fumble.

Concerning INTs, I emphasized that ending opponents’ possessions is most salient and that INT return yardage is a somewhat superfluous stat. INT return yards may be useful to compare playmaking abilities between DBs, although statisticians, teams, and observers might be better served knowing the SFP that resulted from an interception. This notion is definitely applicable for fumble returns where, again, the ending of opponents’ possession is most salient.

Likewise, it is also relevant for rating punt returners. For instance, a player fair catching a punt at his own 9-yard line would be recorded as a fairly unremarkable zero yards (i.e., it is counted in his average PRY). However, the fair catch was probably initiated in the presence of proximal defenders who could have disrupted the impetus of the punted ball at say, the 2-yard line had the returner declined to fair catch. Thus, by fair catching—despite accruing zero yards—the returner in the example would improve his team’s SFP by 7 yards (of course, the defense downing the ball is hypothetical).

The foregoing notion of field position in lieu of yardage is applicable to kick returns as well. For example, let us review the 2014 NFLleading kick-returners by average yards per return. I have Bruce Ellington of the 49ers at 24 returns for 25.9 yards per return;c.f. he ranks about ninth in KR yards. However, Ellington gives his offensive teammates an average starting FP at the ~23-yard line—18th on my list of qualifying players. It may be poor decision making on his behalf or poor block execution behalf of his teammates or that he generally fields kickoffs from superior kickers but we must acknowledge Ellington’s average catch-spot (CS) on KRs was nearly 3-yards into the endzone, ranking third-deepest on my list of qualifying players.1

Although this post is about SFP, the above anecdotes underscore the entanglement of variables involved in appraising performances with yardage accrued. However, Ellington still gained those yards. If we are comparing players (or even coverage units), perhaps, Ellington does rank ninth in KR yards. However, football is about team success and on a given drive, a team is increasingly inclined to success the closer it begins to its opponent’s endzone. Conversely, Ellington’s team did start 3 yards closer to the endzone then would result from him taking more touchbacks.

Moving on, for all teams in the 2014-15 NFL season, I obtained all non-TD turnover-fumble returns, interceptions, kick and punt returns, and field goals missed by opponents using the Pro-Football Reference PBP searchtool. Opponents’ missed FGs include blocks but excludes blocks returned for TDs. For all plays except opponents’ missed field goals, I extracted [a] the spot of the INT, fumble recovery, or catch and [b] the spot at which the player was downed following the return. Computed with those values were [c] return yards or 20 for a touchback and [d] the SFP of the player’s offensive teammates. SFP was scaled such that teams’ own goal lines equaled zero and opponents’ goal lines equaled 100; greater yards indicate better SFP.



Table 1. Counts, Average SFP, and Average Return Yards for Events Resulting in SFP, NFL 2014-15
TEAM TOTAL EVENT COUNTS AVERAGE STARTING FIELD POSITION BY EVENT AVERAGE RETURN YARDS BY EVENT
KR PR FR INT oMFG SFP KR PR FR INT oMFG KR PR FR INT
KAN 68 76 5 5 5 29.3 25.4 28.7 22.4 44.0 23.6 25.4 8.6 0.0 15.2
CIN 78 74 5 19 5 30.3 24.7 30.3 27.4 50.8 26.0 24.9 8.4 0.0 9.2
NWE 68 64 7 16 5 30.6 22.7 32.0 36.9 51.8 29.6 22.1 7.5 0.4 11.7
DAL 75 66 12 16 2 28.9 21.1 26.9 35.5 43.3 21.0 22.3 7.3 2.6 9.3
TAM 81 63 11 11 7 26.6 20.7 25.3 30.1 48.8 32.6 21.6 7.2 1.3 6.9
IND 79 88 13 11 4 28.7 22.5 28.4 30.3 43.2 24.0 24.3 7.0 2.6 8.7
BAL 68 73 12 10 6 28.7 23.3 30.4 32.9 48.2 27.8 22.9 6.9 4.3 9.1
JAX 92 74 12 5 4 25.7 22.1 21.5 24.3 51.0 31.8 21.9 6.4 0.8 13.0
PHI 83 85 16 9 5 30.0 22.9 28.8 33.8 41.6 23.4 20.9 6.2 6.3 6.2
MIN 73 74 4 11 6 27.3 25.0 25.5 15.3 49.0 30.3 21.9 6.2 0.0 8.2
STL 79 74 11 10 1 28.0 22.1 28.8 32.4 42.1 35.0 22.9 5.9 3.3 10.8
BUF 71 86 8 18 7 30.2 21.3 27.0 25.5 60.4 26.9 20.6 5.9 4.4 19.2
OAK 94 81 4 9 5 24.2 19.9 24.7 26.0 61.9 24.2 21.4 5.7 5.3 8.4
CHI 97 49 8 13 6 25.9 21.1 27.0 15.9 43.6 23.8 20.5 5.6 2.4 10.9
SDG 81 66 8 6 2 26.4 21.3 26.5 24.1 31.7 33.5 21.1 5.5 0.0 12.0
SFO 70 74 5 21 0 27.8 22.6 28.3 16.2 48.0 - 22.9 5.5 0.0 18.8
ATL 89 55 7 15 4 26.5 22.4 25.7 32.3 40.5 27.5 22.5 5.4 5.6 6.9
MIA 82 57 10 11 6 31.1 24.2 25.5 21.3 50.6 23.5 23.9 5.3 0.0 17.1
DEN 75 84 5 16 5 28.9 22.6 28.2 26.0 54.4 25.2 21.4 5.3 0.4 10.8
TEN 89 72 6 11 5 25.8 23.2 24.8 38.8 52.7 31.0 22.5 5.2 7.2 10.8
ARI 76 77 5 15 4 26.9 19.6 24.8 20.8 51.3 32.5 20.2 5.1 1.8 10.3
NYJ 85 79 7 6 5 27.8 22.5 26.6 31.4 35.0 24.0 22.1 5.1 0.3 9.0
PIT 86 66 10 7 2 25.7 20.7 24.9 32.5 48.9 29.5 21.1 5.0 3.9 18.1
NYG 87 74 9 16 2 28.2 20.7 23.7 31.6 62.1 24.0 21.1 4.9 1.5 16.6
GNB 79 60 7 15 1 28.5 20.1 27.0 37.4 54.7 29.0 20.3 4.8 0.0 15.2
CAR 83 69 13 10 4 27.7 21.8 25.5 32.5 45.2 25.8 21.0 4.5 2.8 19.0
SEA 62 81 9 11 2 30.5 22.4 27.7 29.0 58.2 32.5 21.4 4.2 0.0 14.2
CLE 72 83 7 18 3 26.8 22.6 24.9 27.7 54.1 34.0 22.8 4.2 4.9 14.4
WAS 85 80 9 6 3 25.1 21.4 22.7 29.0 45.5 18.0 20.8 4.0 2.1 5.0
HOU 71 82 10 16 2 27.7 20.4 23.5 31.9 60.6 26.5 20.7 3.8 8.7 16.6
DET 70 81 7 18 4 29.9 21.1 29.4 32.9 59.2 27.3 21.8 3.8 1.8 18.7
NOR 86 62 6 12 0 25.5 22.2 22.0 18.5 42.9 - 22.3 3.0 0.0 12.5
League Event Counts Average Field Position by Event Average Return Yards by Event
AVG 79 73 8 12 4 AVG 27.9 22.0 26.5 29.1 50.5 27.2 AVG 22.0 5.6 2.3 12.3
SD 9 10 3 4 2 SD 1.8 1.4 2.5 6.4 7.6 4.2 SD 1.3 1.3 2.4 4.2

Table 1 contains 2014-15 distributions, NFL team average SFP and yards gained for each event, and League averages thereof. KRY and PRY are computed with touchbacks equal to 20 yards and no return equal to zero yards. Neither New Orleans’ nor San Francisco’s opponents missed FGs, apparently. There is nothing particularly noteworthy in the table, otherwise.

I also can tell you several things. INTs have the largest impact on the next-SFP when statistically controlling for the initial play spot, the spot at which an INT, fumble recovery, or kick/punt catch occurred, and the yardage gained on the return.2 I can also tell you that for all NFL teams, the majority of SFP yardage is derived from either KR yards or PR yards. Table 2 provides some insight into why this is.



Table 2. Characteristics of NFL Based on Majority of SFP
Majority of Team SFP From
VARIABLE KR PR
Teams Count 11 21
avg SFP 27 28
avg SFP Unproductive Drives 24 24
avg KR-SFP 22 22
avg Unproductive Drive Yards 17 16
avg Punt Yards 45 45
Opp avg Punt Return Yards 9 9
avg Def. SFP After Unproductive Drive 24 23
Opp avg Unproductive Drive Yards 16 16
Opp avg Punt Yards 45 45
avg Punt Return Yards 5 6
% All Drives Turnovers 14% 11%
Opp % All Drives Turnovers 12% 12%
% All Drives End w/ Score 32% 35%
Opp % All Drives End w/ Score 39% 32%
win% 35% 58%
NOTE: Unproductive drives are defined as those that end without a score.
Scoring drives are those that ended in TDs or FGs.


In Table 2 we see that the two types of teams perform similarly in most situations. Notably, teams whose majority of SFP is derived from KRs commit TOs slightly more frequently. As an aside, this might suggest that while essentially random, a modicum of TOs may be attributable to offensive ineptitude (albeit, in single season sample). Those teams’ opponents also end drives by scoring considerably more frequently—23% more—than teams whose majority of SFP is derived from PRs. The PR-teams score slightly more frequently.

Most striking in Table 2, though, is the disparity in win percentage. The KR-teams can be expected to win 5.6 games whereas PR-teams can be expected to win 9.3 games. Thus, I conclude that, despite the indelible impact of Devon Hester or the ’84 Seahawks’ 3-4 monster, ultimately, SFP is largely the result of an ungenerous defense supplemented by relatively consistent and careful offensive play.

Summarily, the impact of various events on starting field position was examined using data from the 2014-15 NFL season. Although INT yards are most impactful on SFP in isolation, when statistically controlling for event-spot and return yardage, the majority of SFP is derived from either KR or PR yards. Likewise, winning teams garner most of their from PR yards. I concluded that this effect is likely due to defensive stops and consistent, careful offensive play.



1 Minimum 1 KR per game scheduled.
2 To accomplish this, SFP was regressed on to play start spot, event spot, and yards gained. The residuals were saved. An ANOVA was performed with those residuals as the dependent variable and event type as the independent variable. A significant effect of event type was found, F(4, 5641) = 17.422, p < .001. Roughly, planned post hoc comparisons indicate the effect of event on SFP could be ranked as INT > FUM > PR > MFG > KR.

Monday, May 30, 2016

More Kick and Punt Return TDs are Surrendered Early in the NFL Season


I was recently reading about football as I often do. For the uninformed reader, my preference is for the collegiate game but I do possess a certain fondness for the professional game. It fascinates me, the extent to which many professionals prepare for and intellectually categorize the intricacies of such a violent game. The machinations of pro football that occur away from the gridiron, on days other than Sunday and during the offseason are intriguing as well. This, notwithstanding the machinations of pro pigskin that I detest.

Anyhow, I was reading Take Your Eyes off the Ball authored by Pat Kerwin. I enjoyed his anatomization of team management activities in the League. In brief, it is a quality read for the novice football fan interested in learning about Xs and Os, team management operations, or both.

In his discussion of special teams play, Kerwin asserts that we “often see a flurry of punts and kickoffs returned for touchdowns [during] the first three weeks of the season.” He attributes this effect to poor management of practice time, roster turnover and the limitations of a 53-man roster, and coverage teams often being comprised of inexperienced players.

I was interested in testing Kerwin’s assertion. Data were culled from the Football Reference Play Finder for seasons 2009-15. I divided the 16-game NFL regular season into quadrants: team-games 1-4, 5-8, and so on, and computed six variables for each quadrant: 
  • punt return (PR) and kickoff return (KR) TDs; 
  • PRs and KRs that were not TDs; 
  • and punts and kickoffs with no return (NR).

Table 1. Observed and Expected Values for NFL Kickoff Outcomes 2009-15
OBSERVED EXPECTED
GAMES Kickoffs KRTD KR NR KRTD KR NR
1-4 4406 18 2171 2217 16.8 2489.4 1899.8
5-8 4467 21 2480 1966 17.0 2523.9 1926.1
9-12 4382 14 2620 1748 16.7 2475.9 1889.5
13-16 4343 14 2672 1657 16.5 2453.8 1872.6
TOTAL 17598 67 9943 7588
Data for KRs and PRs appear in Table 1 and 2, respectively. The values included are the quantities of TDs, returns, and NRs that were observed and those that would be expected given the proportions that emerged. This arrangement is suited for a Chi-square test of independence because that is the analysis we will use. Though excluded for visibility, do note that expected-column totals equal that of observed-columns.

Table 2. Observed and Expected Values for NFL Punt Outcomes 2009-15
OBSERVED EXPECTED
GAMES Punts PRTD PR NR PRTD PR NR
1-4 4137 30 1833 2274 24.3 1807.9 2304.8
5-8 4193 19 1874 2300 24.6 1832.4 2336.0
9-12 4295 27 1892 2376 25.2 1876.9 2392.8
13-16 4233 23 1768 2442 24.9 1849.8 2358.3
TOTAL 16858 99 7367 9392

KR TDs are observed more than would be expected during the 1-4 and 5-8 team-games of the season and less than would be expected in the latter quadrants, χ2(6, N = 17,598) = 160.34, p <.001, φC = .067. Given the effect size (φC), we conclude that there is a small but significant disparity in the distribution of KR TDs throughout the season. Although we observed differences in PR TD distributions, the distributional disparities through the season appear minimal, χ2(6, N = 16,858) = 11.98, p = .062, φC = .019. However, it is worth noting that PR TDs during the first four games of the season are probably occurring more than would be expected, supporting Kerwin’s hypothesis.

Chi-square tests indicate that Kerwin is accurate in his assertions. NFL teams surrender more KR and PR TDs early in the season. However, this analysis merely tests the distribution of observed PR/KR TDs and what would be expected to happen given those observations. That is, we are unable to test the influence of poor management of practice time, roster turnover, inexperience, etc. The present analysis does provide a foundation for future studies of the foregoing variables.

Saturday, April 2, 2016

Comparison of WNBA and NBA League-wide Team Data

Monday 30 MAY 2016. Update: I prepared and published this post in a haste only to realize while in the shower several days later the mistaken inclusion of three variables in the Table of this post: "ORB / FG missed", "DRB / FG missed", and "Dead Ball Rebounds". With the data that was used in computation, these are inaccurate and meaningless statistics because rebounds can be gathered on missed shots as well as missed freethrows and we are unable to distinguish from league and team totals whether rebounds were gathered on FGAs or FTAs. Likewise, Dead Ball Rebounds was inaccurately included in my haste and computation of such a statistic would require additional data. Apologies.

Point guard of the WNBA Seattle Storm Sue Bird contributed to a recent installment of the 538 podcast HotTakedown. Bird’s appearance was precipitated by an op-ed she authored for the Player’s Tribune illuminating the paucity of accessible, informative data for the WNBA and for female sports more broadly. Days later, hysteria followed comments made by a veteran sports writer regarding the unprecedented dominance of the UConn women basketball team. The implications of that writer’s statement have been summarized elsewhere.

After listening to Sue Bird on the 538 podcast and before learning of the galvanizing comments, I watched much of Uconn’s decimation of Mississippi State. I watched because I enjoy that sort of competitive dominance; plus, their team is just good. I’ve yet to write about it here but I also watched because I love basketball. After hearing the galvanizing comments, all I could think was: with increased access to informative data and with an array of perspectives creating narratives using such data, maybe a weakness would be identified.
Admittedly, I watch less female than male basketball but that is partly attributable to the greater viewing options for the latter. In my opinion, the female game demands greater acceptance of and adherence to strategy. Also, it appears that fewer female players exhibit an inclination to rely on and expect officiating. There are absolutely aspects of female basketball that I prefer. That should be unsurprising—consider the blog title—because there is simply less palming of the ball, at least in my observational comparisons of the female and male varieties.
 

Indeed, there is diversity and variety in the female and the male games. This post is devoted to a simple exploration of that variety. The data in Table 1 was computed using league-wide WNBA and NBA data from the 2015 and 2014-15 regular seasons, respectively. Data from Basketball Reference. Possessions were estimated with an equation used by ESPN.com and NBA.com, developed I believe by legend Dean Oliver. 

Table 1. Comparison of WNBA and NBA League-wide Team Data for Regular Season Ending 2015
SHOOTING
STAT WNBA NBA
FG% 42.5% 44.9%
3FG% 32.5% 35.0%
2FG% 45.4% 48.5%
FT% 79.5% 75.0%
% of FGA are 2PA 77.4% 73.2%
% of FGA are 3PA 22.6% 26.8%
ORB / FG Missed 23.4% 23.6%
DRB / FG Missed 65.9% 70.4%
Dead Ball RBs 10.7% 6.0%
Assists / FGs 58.7% 58.7%
Blocks / FGA 6.6% 5.7%
FT / FGA 22.6% 20.1%
FTA / FGA 28.4% 27.3%
POSSESSIONS
FGA / POSS 0.877 0.897
Fouls / POSS 0.248 0.217
Turnovers / POSS 0.173 0.154
Steals / POSS 0.096 0.083
Pts / POSS 1.008 1.073
Pts / FGA 0.923 0.992
Pace 88.7 92.5
A few items of note upon review of this table. Offenses in both leagues rebound their own misses at similar rates and assist FGs at essentially identical rates. The pace of the NBA game is somewhat faster. In the WNBA there appears to be a greater proportion of dead-ball rebounds the cause of which is unclear. Also, for what it’s worth, the NBA teams scored .069 points per possession more than did WNBA teams. 

Before concluding, I would like to provide some depth to the discrepancies in FG% between the two leagues. NBA players tallied 8793 successful dunks in 2014-15 season. From what I can ascertain, there were maybe 2 dunks in the 2015 WNBA season. Successful dunking is nearly guaranteed, although NBA did make only 91% of dunk attempts. Contrarily, NBA players sunk 27,080 lay-ups that season at a clip of 58%. As you know, we don’t have that sort of data for the WNBA; well, at least I don’t. 

So how does the discrepancy change if we exclude all dunk attempts from the computation of NBA FG%? We’ll even remove the 2 WNBA dunks. Excluding dunk attempts, NBA FG% drops from 45% to 40%. Considering that FG%, WNBA players appear to shoot a higher percentage that is statistically significant, but it is a small effect.[1] Now, it should be noted that the WNBA players do play with a slightly smaller and lighter-weight ball, about 96.6% the circumference of the NBA ball and 91% the weight of the NBA ball but the rim diameters are equal. Thus, the argument could be made that there is a greater area of the basket plane available for the WNBA ball to enter the basket. 

There is evidence to suggest that basketball of light weightwill facilitate increased FG%. We do know that Illinois males played Oakland in December 2010. The first 7:22 of game time was played with the slightly smaller ball used by females. Illinois did shoot 3 of 13 in that time and Oakland shot 7 of 16. That is a small sample, however, there appears to be a lack of effect of ball size on free throw shooting percentage and on shooting kinematics. Moreover, one study compared collegiate 71 female and 35 male basketballers. Neither an effect of ball size nor weight was found for on “side shots” (elbow jumper) and “lay ups” but smaller, lighter balls were passed fastest by both sexes. 

I provided in this post a comparison of the WNBA and NBA league-wide team data. However, I was not attempting a comparison, per se. More precisely, I attempted to highlight the variety of game-play in each League and how that variety manifests statistically because, when informative statistics are tracked for female basketball, it is not enough to simply adopt existing metrics from the male game—ecological considerations specific to the female game are warranted. Simple calculations were used to demonstrate how the high-percentage of successful dunking inflates FG%s in the NBA. Likewise, the effect of ball-size was considered. In sum, this exploratory analysis indicates several avenues of further study of the statistical manifestations of female basketball including, the high proportion of dead ball rebounds and slight differences in turnovers, fouls, steals, and blocked shot-attempts to their male counterparts.

[1] χ2(df = 1, N = 27055) = 103.35, p < .001, Ṽ  = .061.